Today’s Wall Street Journal profiled some excerpts from the wsj.com/lawblog, written by Peter Lattman, including a January 16, 2008 story about a law school graduate who regrets her decision to attend law school. Kirsten Wolf, a 32 year old Boston University Law School grad who incurred over $100,000 in law school debt, says that she is on a one-woman mission to talk others out of going to law school. Wolf, who has found her dream job as an office manager for a literary agency, says that she initially decided to go to law school to satisfy her intellectual interests and so she “wouldn’t be poor.” However, she quickly realized that the lucrative law firm jobs went to only a few students at the top of the class, and with average grades, she could only hope for a miracle. So Wolf finished law school, incurring massive debt, and ultimately landing a non-legal job that pays significantly less than a large law firm associate salary. Although Wolf loves her current position, as she describes it, she will be paying off law school debt until five years before “social security kicks in.”
Wolf admits that she did acquire some legal skills in law school, but laments that it was not worth $100,000 of debt. This topic hits close to home because I am also a law school grad and I understand Wolf’s frustration with the choice to attend law school. Although I, fortunately, did not incur the kind of debt that Wolf did, I also faced serious doubts about whether my career decision was the right one. Having learned through my own experience and through talking to other dissatisfied attorneys, I think that aspiring law school attendees must think long and hard before committing to three years of law school and potential school debt the size of a home mortgage. Although Wolf’s primary grip seems to be that she incurred enormous debt without a payoff in the form of a lucrative job after law school, I question whether Wolf would have been satisfied with her career choice even had she gotten a law firm position with a six-figure starting salary. A relative of mine who attended also attended BU law school did get a law firm position with a starting salary of $160,000 plus bonus. However, she was completely miserable, working the hourly equivalent of two full time jobs and performing such non-glamorous tasks like sitting in a windowless room going through stacks of discovery documents. As soon as her husband secured a high-paying position, she promptly quit the law firm and went to work for a non-profit. I’ve also had colleagues who have stayed at law firms, even though they were very unhappy, because of the “golden handcuffs.” Not only were they paying off school debt, they also spent money to buy large homes, expensive cars, and designer clothes as a form of therapy to make themselves feel that the endless billable hours were worth it. I know this because I have been there myself. I still have some clothes hanging in the closet with tags on them from when I worked at a firm that frequently required nights and weekend work.
According to a February 1, 2006, National Law Journal article, “As Salaries Rise, So Does the Debt,” by Leigh Jones, law school tuition is increasing at a far faster pace than law firm salaries, meaning that today’s law school grads grapple with proportionally higher debt levels than past law school grads. With 80 percent of law school grads obtaining financial aid, and average loan debt for private schools at $77,000 and public school at $49,000, the decision to attend law school is one of the most significant financial decisions in your life.
So, before you decide to attend law school, do the following:
- Work at a law firm, as a temp, secretary, paralegal, to get a feel about what it is like to be a private lawyer
- Talk to lawyers in private practice, public service, and government about their experiences
- Decide what kind of law you want to practice. If you are just going to law school, because you don’t have any idea what to do next, DON’T.
- Decide how frugally you can live and how much savings you can accumulate before entering law school, to minimize debt
- Talk to graduates of the law school you are thinking of attending, to see how satisfied they are with the experience. If you run into a lot of disgruntled graduates who are unhappy with the job placement and the value of their juris doctorate degree, it might be a good idea to look at other schools
I’m not discouraging anyone from attending law school, just advising them to DO THE HOMEWORK. Choosing law school means a lot of money and may influence your career path for the rest of your life. It’s worth taking the time to crunch the numbers and decide whether you really want to make this commitment. One final note: law practice is the furthest thing from L.A. Law and Ally McBeal.